Food review blog from San Francisco.

Restaurant: Acme Chophouse (San Francisco)
Food description: 22oz grain-finished bone-in rib eye steak (medium rare)
Food rating: 8 out of 10
Times ordered: 2

The ribeye is the only grain-finished steak on the menu at Acme (aside from specials), so I thought I'd compare it tete-a-tete against one of their esteemed grass-fed steaks: the porterhouse. The verdict? Let's just say the rib eye was quite good, but was no match for the porterhouse. Sure, certain aspects are a matter of personal preference--some people prefer the fattiness of the rib eye--but in terms of texture and flavor, the porterhouse was far superior. If you're big on rib eye though, you won't be disappointed with Acme's. All of their steaks are grilled in an oak-burning oven, the key to their characteristic deep smoky flavor. The rib eye itself was as juicy as it was greasy, due to the extra marbling from the grain-finishing. That makes the rib eye the heaviest richest steak they offer. If you're in the mood for something leaner and lighter-tasting, then grass-fed is the way to go. Though the flavor of the rib eye was delicious, I was less impressed with the texture, and found it to be slightly on the tough side. The outer lip was tender and just fine, but the inside required a bit more chewing effort. The porterhouse was much more tender. I'm itching to try their special 40 day dry-aged rib eye and see how it stacks up (but someone else nabbed the last one from my clutches). So until then, it's the porterhouse all the way.